In 2001, two of Charles Darwin’s notebooks were found missing from a Cambridge library. 21 years later someone left them on the floor outside the librarian’s office in a pink gift bag with a typed note reading Happy Easter
On March 9, 2022, someone left a bright pink gift bag on the floor outside the University Librarian’s office, on the fourth floor of Cambridge University Library’s 17-story tower. Inside was a blue archive box. Inside that, wrapped together in cling film, were two small notebooks that had not been seen by the library in more than 21 years.
They were Charles Darwin’s. One of them holds the 1837 sketch now known as his Tree of Life.
A box that never came back
The trail starts in September 2000. According to the appeal Cambridge University Library published in 2020, the two notebooks were taken out of the Special Collections Strong Rooms, where the rarest items are kept, so they could be photographed.
Then, during a routine check in January 2001, staff found that the small box holding both notebooks, about the size of a paperback, had not been put back in its place. For many years, some librarians assumed it had simply been misfiled somewhere in a building that holds around 10 million books, maps, manuscripts and other objects. Several searches over the following years turned up nothing.
Lost becomes stolen
At the start of 2020, University Librarian Jessica Gardner organized the largest search in the library’s history, with specialist staff assigned to particular zones of storage and fingertip checks where needed. The team went through the entire Darwin Archive, all 189 archive boxes.
The notebooks were not there.
With advice from national experts on cultural heritage theft, the library concluded they had likely been stolen. On November 24, 2020, the anniversary of the publication of On the Origin of Species, it went public. Cambridgeshire Police had been informed, the notebooks were added to Interpol’s database of stolen artworks, and Gardner asked anyone who knew anything to come forward. “I am heartbroken that the location of these Darwin notebooks, including Darwin’s iconic ‘Tree of Life’ drawing, is currently unknown,” she said at the time.
The library said their value was hard to estimate but would probably run into millions of pounds. Gardner also acknowledged how differently the loss had been handled. “Security policy was different 20 years ago,” she said. “Today any such significant missing object would be reported as a potential theft immediately and a widespread search begun.”
Why these two notebooks matter
The pair are known as Notebooks B and C, part of what are called the Transmutation Notebooks. Darwin was writing in them in 1837, not long after returning from his voyage around the world aboard HMS Beagle, as he began working out how species might change from ancestral forms into later ones.
The Tree of Life sketch sits in Notebook B, under two words Darwin wrote above it: “I think.” It came more than two decades before he published a far more developed tree in On the Origin of Species in 1859. Both had been digitized, so their contents could still be read online while the originals were missing.
“Librarian, Happy Easter”
The return came 15 months after the appeal launched. Along with the archive box, the pink bag held a plain brown envelope addressed to the University Librarian, carrying a short printed message: “Librarian / Happy Easter / X.” The notebooks were in good condition, with no obvious signs of significant handling or damage, according to the university’s announcement on April 5, 2022.
There was no CCTV covering the area outside the librarian’s office, though cameras watch the building’s entrances and exits, Gardner told reporters, according to ITV News Anglia. Footage was handed to police. “It really is a mystery,” she said. “We don’t know how and we don’t know who.”
“My sense of relief at the notebooks’ safe return is profound and almost impossible to adequately express,” Gardner said in the university’s statement. She credited the public appeal: “We believe that decision has had a direct bearing on the notebooks being returned.”
Still an open case
Cambridgeshire Police said its investigation remained open and that it was following up some lines of inquiry. As far as we can tell, no one has been publicly identified as either the thief or the person who brought the notebooks back.
The library put the notebooks on show that summer. Its exhibition Darwin in Conversation, which opened on July 9, 2022, displayed the Tree of Life sketch to the public for the first time this century. “They may be tiny, just the size of postcards,” Gardner said, “but the notebooks’ impact on the history of science, and their importance to our world-class collections here, cannot be overstated.”
