In 2018, a Banksy painting shredded itself moments after it sold at Sotheby’s for £1.04 million, and three years later the buyer put the half-shredded canvas back up for auction and it sold for £18.6 million, a record for the artist
On the evening of 5 October 2018, the auctioneer at Sotheby’s in London brought down his hammer on the final lot of the night. Banksy’s Girl with Balloon, a painting of a young girl reaching towards a red heart-shaped balloon, had just sold for £1,042,000.
Seconds later, an alarm sounded. The canvas began sliding down through its heavy gilded frame and came out the bottom in strips. The room gasped as staff hurried to lift the picture off the wall, now half shredded.
A famous image
Girl with Balloon first appeared as a stencil on walls in London in the early 2000s, including near Waterloo Bridge on the South Bank. It became one of Banksy’s best-known images, reproduced on posters, mugs and T-shirts. In 2017, it was voted the UK’s favourite artwork in a public poll.
Banksy, an anonymous street artist believed to have started out in Bristol, often uses his work to poke fun at power, war and money. The painting sold at Sotheby’s in 2018 was a version on canvas, which Banksy had given to a friend in 2006.
The shredder in the frame
Banksy soon revealed that the stunt was planned. He posted a video showing a shredder built secretly into the picture frame years earlier, “in case it was ever put up for auction”. It appears someone in the room triggered the device by remote control.
The shredder stopped halfway, leaving the top half of the canvas intact in the frame and the bottom hanging out in thin strips. Banksy later suggested it had been meant to shred the entire painting.
A new artwork is born
The buyer, an anonymous European collector, was given the option to withdraw from the sale. Instead, they decided to keep the work. Banksy’s authentication body, Pest Control, issued a new certificate and gave the piece a new name: Love is in the Bin.
The art world treated the shredded canvas as a new piece of performance art in its own right. In 2019, it went on public display at the Staatsgalerie Stuttgart in Germany, where visitors queued to see it.
Back under the hammer
On 14 October 2021, almost exactly three years after the shredding, Love is in the Bin returned to the same Sotheby’s saleroom in London. This time, the auction house estimated it would sell for between £4 million and £6 million.
Nine bidders competed for around 10 minutes. The hammer finally fell at £16 million, and with fees the total came to £18,582,000. That made it the most expensive Banksy ever sold at auction, beating the £16.75 million paid earlier that year for Game Changer, a painting honouring NHS workers that was sold to raise money for health charities.
Why the price soared
The shredding turned a well-known painting into a famous moment in art history. Banksy had seemingly set out to mock the art market, but the stunt made the work far more valuable.
The story also reflected a booming market for Banksy’s work. Despite the artist’s criticism of wealthy collectors, his paintings have become some of the most sought-after works by any living British artist.
A record that still stands
More than five years later, Love is in the Bin remains the highest price ever paid for a Banksy at auction. Other works have come close, but none has matched it.
For many, the story captures Banksy perfectly: a joke at the art world’s expense that the art world turned into one of its biggest success stories. The painting that was meant to destroy itself ended up being worth almost 20 times more.
