Skip to content

British history, travel, and culture

History

In 1966 a young art teacher paid less than $100 for an oil painting of a woman in black in a New York thrift shop, and 60 years later it went home to Edinburgh as the work of a Scottish painter and sold for £189,200

Stock image from Pexels. For illustrative purposes only.

In 1966, Helene Plotkin, an art teacher then in her late 20s, was looking for things to hang in her new home. In a charity shop in White Plains, a suburb north of New York City, she found an oil painting of a woman in black sitting in a brightly colored room. It cost her less than $100. It hung on her living room wall for 60 years.

In June 2026, the same canvas sold at auction in Edinburgh for £189,200 as the work of the Scottish painter Francis Campbell Boileau Cadell.

A painting with the wrong name

The picture came labeled Portrait of Miss Don Wauchope, and the signature was illegible, according to the Press Association report on the sale. Plotkin, now 88 and living in Florida, bought it on instinct. “My background in art history and studio practice drew me to this piece instantly,” she told PA. “The painting had an undeniable, regal presence, but it was the colour theory at play that held my attention.”

Her son Barry has said he and his brother David used to play American football in front of it. “It’s amazing it survived our childhood,” he told PA, as quoted by Smithsonian magazine.

A son, a chatbot and the back of the canvas

The painting’s identity came out in late 2025, when Barry uploaded a photo of it to Google’s Gemini chatbot. According to Smithsonian, which drew on reporting by The New York Times, the AI pointed to the orange accents, lilac background and Art Deco style as signs of Cadell. It told the family to check the back of the canvas, where they found scrawled numbers, an auction marking and a canvas stamp, and it suggested two specialists at the Edinburgh auction house Lyon & Turnbull, Nick Curnow and Alice Strang.

Strang and Curnow examined the painting under different kinds of light and confirmed it was by Cadell. The specialists also corrected the sitter. She was not Bethia Hamilton Don Wauchope but May Easter, a red-haired model who wears the same turban in Cadell’s portrait Pink and Gold.

A studio in Edinburgh’s New Town

Cadell (1883 to 1937) was one of the four painters now known as the Scottish Colourists, along with Samuel John Peploe, John Duncan Fergusson and George Leslie Hunter. The Lyon & Turnbull catalog calls him “the most Scottish of the group.” He was born in Edinburgh, trained there and in Paris and Munich, lived in the city for most of his life and often wore a kilt.

In 1920, the year after he left the army, he bought 6 Ainslie Place in Edinburgh’s Georgian New Town, across the road from his childhood home at number 22. He painted the front door bright blue to annoy the neighbors and stayed until 1931. The painting shows his north-facing studio on the first floor, which looked over toward Fife. His lilac walls and polished black floor are there, with a bright red chair, a blue and white coffee set and a closed black fan on the tablecloth.

The auction house dates the canvas to the 1920s, which its catalog describes as the most important and successful period of Cadell’s career, and gave it a new title in his own style: Interior: The Lady in Black.

£21 in London, then a thrift shop

The markings on the back also led to an unsolved puzzle. On March 18, 1966, the painting was sold at Christie’s in London as lot 41, under the wrong title, to a buyer recorded as Des Roches, for £21. Within months it was sitting in a charity shop in White Plains.

“How the painting ended up in a charity shop in New York so soon afterwards is a mystery,” Strang told PA.

Back where it was painted

On June 4, 2026, it was lot 132 in the evening session of Lyon & Turnbull’s Scottish Paintings & Sculpture sale in Edinburgh. It sold for £189,200 including buyer’s premium, roughly 9,000 times what it fetched at Christie’s 60 years earlier. Strang said the auction house was “thrilled that this terrific Scottish Colorist work has returned to the city in which it was painted some 100 years later.”

The software supplied a name, but the painting had been picked out long before that by a young teacher with a few dollars to spend. Barry Plotkin put it this way: “For mum, it was confirmation of her artistic eye and ability to recognise great talent.”

The British Heritage newsletter

Britain’s stories, in your inbox

Sign up to get British Heritage stories on history, the royals, travel and culture by email.

From around the web